25 January 2001
Le Monde, journal oblique (continued):
The Shoah: Fictive Images and a Mere Belief?
The photography exposition "Mémoire des camps", currently on view in Paris at the 17th century palace known as the Hôtel de Sully, is stirring up disquiet in some Jewish circles. This exposition, from which care has been taken to eliminate a few too patent fakes, makes glaring, in our materialist age of the image, of photography and television, the absence of any photograph and of any material element which might prove that the Jews were, during the 1939-1945 war, "victims of an industrially planned extermination". Those last six words are of Jacques Mandelbaum, a regular journalist at the daily Le Monde. In an article entitled "La Shoah et ces images qui nous manquent" ("The Shoah and those images which we lack", 25 January 2001, p.17), he does not hide his puzzlement.
He writes that "no [true] images describing this crime are available". He speaks, with regard to Auschwitz, of Soviet "propaganda pictures". He adds:
Some of these [Soviet propaganda] pictures were nonetheless reused afterwards as true archival documents. All the known images concerning this crime are thus, if not false, at least inappropriate. Including, and perhaps especially, those of the mounds of corpses discovered in the concentration camps, the spectacular horror of which is still far from the reality.
He reminds the reader that it is precisely because of the non-existence
of real images that it has been "possible to produce images
by way of fiction", and he thinks that fiction "is in
the process of winning out". The organisers of the exposition
go so far as to assert, as has Jean-Claude Pressac, that such
or such a photograph was taken from inside an Auschwitz gas chamber.
Sceptical, the journalist asks: "from a gas chamber or from
Despite objections voiced on the subject by revisionists, certain authors had dared to claim that, in the photographs taken in 1944 by Allied pilots from high above the Auschwitz complex, the buildings containing the homicidal gas chambers could be made out. J. Mandelbaum notes that, in these photographs, all "things existing at Auschwitz can be deciphered, except the presence of the gas chambers". He returns to "the insufferable lack of [real] images of the extermination", and he mentions a dispute amongst exterminationist authors "literally haunted by the near-total absence of photos relating to the extermination". In passing, he assails "the ineptness of the [exposition,s] organisers".
In sum, this Shoah, of which he of course upholds the historical character, is reduced for the moment, on the one hand, to fictive images (he says "images largely inappropriate") and, on the other hand, to a belief, itself founded on fictive images.
If seeing is believing, how can it be admitted henceforth that, with regard to the Shoah, the [real] image is precisely what is lacking?
That last question, which is clear, and all of those remarks,
which are not lacking in punch, are wrested with much difficulty
from the fuzzy mass of the article. The journalist employs manifold
contortions of language, writing in a Yeshiva-style French. He
seeks systematically to save the holocaustic stake and, indeed,
perhaps also to leave an eventual way out for himself and his
newspaper. Thus Le Monde, come the day when the myth of the Shoah
has to be scuttled, will be able to pride itself on this article
of J. Mandelbaum's and on a few other equally oblique ones.
More than twenty years ago, in the face of the revisionist upsurge, Pierre Vidal-Naquet and his co-religionists began beating a retreat, disowning some of the more blatant lies of their own propaganda. Over the years, they have acquired the habit of laying those fallacious inventions at the door of the Communists, the Russians, or the Poles. Here it is apparent that the Le Monde journalist imputes the counterfeit coin of Auschwitz to the Soviets.
First displayed on aaargh: 17 April 2001.
This text has been displayed on the Net, and forwarded to you as a tool for educational purpose, further research, on a non commercial and fair use basis, by the International Secretariat of the Association des Anciens Amateurs de Recits de Guerres et d'Holocaustes (AAARGH). The E-mail of the Secretariat is <[email protected]. Mail can be sent at PO Box 81475, Chicago, IL 60681-0475, USA..
We see the act of displaying a written document on Internet as the equivalent to displaying it on the shelves of a public library. It costs us a modicum of labor and money. The only benefit accrues to the reader who, we surmise, thinks by himself. A reader looks for a document on the Web at his or her own risks. As for the author, there is no reason to suppose that he or she shares any responsibilty for other writings displayed on this Site. Because laws enforcing a specific censorship on some historical question apply in various countries (Germany, France, Israel, Switzerland, Canada, and others) we do not ask their permission from authors living in thoses places: they wouldn't have the freedom to consent.
We believe we are protected by the Human Rights Charter:
ARTICLE 19. <Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.>The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the United Nations General Assembly on December 10, 1948, in Paris.